Soames aims to integrate and deepen the most significant insights on truth from a variety of sources. Precis of beyond rigidity, philosophical studies 10. In naming and necessity saul kripke undermined descriptive analyses of names by showing that names are rigid designators. Rigidity, general terms, and recognitional capacities i it is often claimed that kripke 1980 and putnam 1975 established that many general terms, most importantly natural kind terms, are like proper names in being rigid designators. Suppose that n is a name and the d is a description or cluster thereof that is supposed to give the semantic content of n. Generalizing soames argument against rigidified descriptivism. His other books include reference and description princeton, beyond rigidity, and understanding truth. The unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity by scott soames beyond rigidity. The unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity scott soames download bok. He is a distinguished professor of philosophy at the graduate center of the. Read beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity, journal of pragmatics on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. A contemporary introduction 2000 soames, beyond rigidity 2002 soames, philosophical analysis. This excellent book is aptly titled, for in it scott soames systematically discusses and greatly extends the semantic views that saul kripke presen ted in naming and necessity. Part 1 is devoted to the semantics and pragmatics of names, and the sentences, including attitude ascriptions, that.
Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century, volume 2. This excellent book is aptly titled, for in it scott soames systematically discusses and greatly extends the semantic views that saul kripke presented in naming and necessity. Critical notice of scott soames, beyond rigidity michael mckinsey wayne state university in this admirable book, scott soames provides well defended answers to some of the most difficult and important questions in the philosophy of language, and he. The best books on the philosophy of language five books.
A very recent booklength treatment by a defender of direct reference kripkes puzzle concerning belief donnellan k. Canadian journal of philosophy critical notice of scott. Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century, volume 2 by. Beyond rigidity the unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity by scott soames. However, this extension of the notion of rigid designation to cover general terms has proved difficult in. Fuck yeah logical, analytic philosophy reading list for the. Consider a sentence of the form, if the fexists, then the fis f.
Soames firmly asserts that linguistic analysis is not sufficient for the study of metaphysical modality, and that. Review of scott soames, beyond rigidity, linguistics and philosophy 26 2003, pp. Beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic agenda of naming and. Pdf critical notice of soames, beyond rigidity michael. Scott soames, beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity, oxford.
Critical notice of scott soames, beyond rigidity michael mckinsey wayne state university in this admirable book, scott soames provides well defended answers to some of the most difficult and important questions in the philosophy of language, and he does so with characteristic thoroughness, clarity, and rigor. He gives meanings of proper names and natural kind predicates and explains their use in attitude ascri. Beyond rigidity on scott soamesi filosoofiline raamat. Soames is explicit about his antideflationary agenda. Reply, authormario g\omeztorrente and scott soames, year2004 i offer a brief formal exploration of a certain natural extension of the notion of rigidity to. Beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic agenda of naming. Scott soames has recently weighed in on this issue in the latter chapters of his book beyond rigidity. Philosophical essays, volume 1 princeton university press. Scott soames, beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic.
He gives meanings of proper names and natural kind predicates and explains their use in attitude. Soames retains the core of millianism by claiming that sentences containing names stand in a relation of semantic expression to singular propositions propositions containing the referents of those names as constituents. Hale and wright, a companion to the philosophy of language 1997 stroll, twentiety century analytic philosophy 2000 lycan, philosophy of language. Naming, necessity, and beyond1 nathan salmon beyond rigidity, by scott soames. Rigidity for the common noun michael johnsons homepage. The case against twodimensionalism by scott soames in djvu, fb2, rtf download ebook. Since the 1960s, kripke has been a central figure in a number of fields related to.
The unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity, by scott soames. At that time, he says, the point was not widely appreciated, though the subsequent literature seems to have heard him. Essentialist predication 39 volving them, as well as corresponding theoretical identi. Using a new conception of how the meaning of a sentence relates to the information asserted and conveyed by utterances, soames argues that the meaning of a linguistically simple name is its referent, and. He is a distinguished professor of philosophy at the graduate center of the city university of new york and emeritus professor at princeton university. He gives meanings of proper names and natural kind predicates and explains their use in attitude ascriptions.
Scott soamess excellent book beyond rigidity is in this tradition. Kripkes arguments against the cluster theory can be divided cf. His other books include reference and description princeton, beyond rigidity, and. The unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity1 article in nous 401. He is a professor of philosophy at the university of southern california since 2004, and before that at princeton university. Rigidity, general terms, and recognitional capacities. He also demonstrates the irrelevance of rigid designation in understanding why theoretical identities containing such predicates are. Aim at showing that the referent of n is not linguistically. For more on these arguments, see soames, beyond rigidity. The unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity by scott soames pp. The proposition expressed by this sentence appears to be knowable a priori. He powerfully brings together the best technical work and the most important philosophical reflection on truth and shows how each can illuminate the other.
Scott soames is distinguished professor of philosophy at the university of southern california, specialising in the philosophy of language and the history of analytic philosophy. Essentialist predication and the rigidity of general terms. Philosophical foundations of language in the law oxford. Saul kripke, in a series of classic writings of the 1960s and 1970s, changed the face of metaphysics and philosophy of language. Philosophical analysis in the twentieth century is a critical examination of key texts and trends in analytic philosophy by one of its leading contemporary practitioners. He has published extensively on truth, reference, meaning, the relationship between semantics and pragmatics, and the nature of syntactic and semantic theories of. Soames has applied his formidable forensic talents to highlight the insights and expose the errors of the major figures from moore to kripke. But he additionally invokes a relation of assertion. Read download naming and necessity pdf pdf download.
Reviewed by jaroslav peregrin, department of logic, institute of philosophy, academy of sciences of the czech republic, jilska 1, 110 00 praha 1, czech republic. The semantic argument 7885 kripke has two other arguments against the descriptive theory. Scott soames, beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic agenda of. Part 1 is devoted to the semantics and pragmatics of names, and the sentences, including attitude ascriptions, that contain them. In this fascinating work, scott soames offers a new conception of the relationship between linguistic meaning and assertions made by utterances.
Scott soames is director of the school of philosophy at the university of southern california. His books include reference and description princeton, philosophical analysis in the twentieth century, volumes 1 and 2 princeton, beyond rigidity, and understanding truth. All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by us and international laws. In naming and necessity saul kripke criticized descriptivist theories of proper names and suggested a better picture as a replacement. Scott soames is professor of philosophy at the university of southern california. Request pdf on jun 1, 2003, jaroslav peregrin and others published beyond rigidity, the unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity. Naming and necessity is a 1980 book with the transcript of three lectures, given by the philosopher saul kripke, at princeton university in 1970, in which he dealt with the debates of proper names in the philosophy of language. Sep 12, 2005 precis of beyond rigidity soames, scott 20050912 00.
Christopher hughes offers a careful exposition and critical analysis of kripkes central ideas about names, necessity, and identity. The moving wall represents the time period between the last issue available in jstor and the most recently published issue of a journal. The unfinished semantic agenda of naming and necessity. His conclusion is that although there are significant overlaps in the properties of singular and general terms, there is no direct extension of rigidity to the general terms, and that rigid. An individual user may print out a pdf of a single chapter of a monograph in oso for. He claims that there is a fundamental metaphysical disagreement between himself and the deflationist, rather than just a linguistic quibble. In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a zero moving wall, so their current issues are available.
596 238 1373 750 1099 971 1161 1274 1394 1091 192 1407 1098 318 1350 450 605 534 159 1076 621 1549 1595 368 1161 1339 154 1443 1363 1209 470 1390 1173